Scandinavian Working Papers in Economics

Working Paper Series,
Research Institute of Industrial Economics

No 1277: A Meritocratic Origin of Egalitarian Behavior

Alexander W. Cappelen , Johanna Möllerström (), Bjørn-Atle Reme and Bertil Tungodden
Additional contact information
Alexander W. Cappelen: FAIR at the Norwegian School of Economics, Postal: Bergen, Norway
Johanna Möllerström: Interdisciplinary Center for Economic Science (ICES), Postal: the Economics Department, George Mason University, Fairfax, VA, and Research Institute for Industrial Economics, Stockholm, Sweden
Bjørn-Atle Reme: Telenor Research, Postal: Oslo, Norway and Norwegian School of Economics, Bergen, Norway
Bertil Tungodden: FAIR at the Norwegian School of Economics, Postal: Bergen, Norway

Abstract: The meritocratic fairness ideal implies that inequalities in earnings are regarded as fair only when they reflect differences in performance. Consequently, implementation of the meritocratic fairness ideal requires complete information about individual performances, but in practice, such information is often not available. We study redistributive behavior in the common, but previously understudied, situation where there is uncertainty about whether inequality is reflecting performance or luck. We show theoretically that meritocrats in such situations can become very egalitarian in their behavior, and that the degree to which this happens depends on how they trade off the probability of making mistakes and the size of mistakes that they risk making when redistributing under uncertainty. Our laboratory experiments show, in line with our model, that uncertainty about the source of inequality provides a strong egalitarian pull on the behavior of meritocrats. In addition, the external validity of our framework, and the results from the laboratory, are supported in two general population surveys conducted in the United States and Norway.

Keywords: Inequality; Fairness; Redistribution; Responsibility; Performance; Luck; Experiment; Survey

JEL-codes: C91; D63; D81; H23

62 pages, May 13, 2019

Full text files

wp1277.pdf PDF-file Full text

Download statistics

Questions (including download problems) about the papers in this series should be directed to Elisabeth Gustafsson ()
Report other problems with accessing this service to Sune Karlsson ().

This page generated on 2020-02-16 18:56:33.